become expert | help | login
refer a friend - earn nickels!!
 advanced

  Ask & Discuss Questions with Community & Experts

Moderation Team
  500 chars left
Ask experts Expert Question: electrostats
Reply Forum Index -> Electricity originally posted here on IIT-JEE / AIEEE community   
Email  
Author Message
vijay kharya (514)

Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer. 86  [128 rates]

vijay kharya's Avatar

total posts: 634    
Offline

An electric dipole is placed at the centre of a sphere. then

 

A) the flux of the electric field through the sphere is zero.

 

 

B) the electric field is zero at every point on the sphere.

 

C) the electric field is not zero anywhere on the sphere.

 

 

D) the electric field is zero on a circle on the sphere.

 

 

in arihant ch21 (electrostats) ans is given A,C, but in the question if it has been mentioned that the dipole  is placed at the centre of the sphere then cant we assume that it is a short dipole and then option B and D are  correct and not option C.

plz. reply rates assured


sucess is not a faithful girlfriend
    
edison (8935)

Forum Expert

Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer. 1561  [2126 rates]

edison's Avatar

total posts: 7537    
Offline

 If you assume the dipole is short then to ignore the dimension of the dipole the condition is that the dimension of sphere( radius in this case) should be >> length of the dipole.

But here nothing is mentioned as far as the dimensions of sphere and dipole is concerned. Thus your assumption holds no ground.

Moreover when dipole is enclosed in the sphere

The total charge enclosed by the sphere = 0

Hence by gauss's law of electrostatics the flux = q / ebsylum = 0

so statement (A) is valid

Also the distribution of charge is not symmetric w.r.t sphere so

(C) electric field is not  zero anywhere on the sphere.


A paradox is an argument that starts with apparently acceptable assumptions and leads by apparently valid deductions to an apparent contradiction. Since logic admits no contradictions, either the apparently acceptable assumptions are not acceptable, or the apparently valid
deductions are not valid, or the apparent contradiction is not a contradiction. A paradox moves us to reexamine the argument until we find out what is wrong.
  this reply:   5 points  (with Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer.   in 1   votes   )     [?]
 
You have to be logged on to rate
  
vijay kharya (514)

Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer. 86  [128 rates]

vijay kharya's Avatar

total posts: 634    
Offline
thank you very much sir,i had the doubt regarding when to ignore the dimensions of the dipole,
  this reply:   0 points  (with Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer.   in 0   votes   )     [?]
 
You have to be logged on to rate
  
mack3turbo (12)

Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer. 2  [3 rates]

mack3turbo's Avatar

total posts: 24    
Offline

ya the explanation given by the above person is absolutely correct

  this reply:   0 points  (with Olaaa!! Perrrfect answer.   in 0   votes   )     [?]
 
You have to be logged on to rate
  
 
reply Forum Index -> Electricity
Go to: 
Sponsored Links